R01: Sakhir, Bahrain
00 00 00 00
Forum - Feedback - Mexico D1 Scores
   
Autor Beiträge
CarlisleFrost

Registriert: 19.03.2009
Nationalität: USA
Beiträge: 132

30.10.2016 23:39:37
  Mexico D1 Scores
Think the scores for Verstappen, Vettel and Ricciardo are wrong for Mexico.

BEFORE the Verstappen time penalty, he was 3rd, so he should be 31 (8 quali + 23 race). Vettel should be 26 (4+22), and Ricciardo should be 33 (7+21+5 fastest lap).

Correct me if I'm wrong!

   
GaKra Motors

Registriert: 02.03.2006
Nationalität: Switzerland
Beiträge: 925

14.11.2016 20:45:40
 
Hillaryous idea @Chris

   
Chris

Registriert: 04.02.2014
Nationalität: Germany
Beiträge: 686

14.11.2016 12:24:48
 
i apply now for a title of hearts atleast for me now ;-)

   
CarlisleFrost

Registriert: 19.03.2009
Nationalität: USA
Beiträge: 132

31.10.2016 00:26:35
 
I don't think a screenshot is really needed. I saw the race. Verstappen crossed the line third, then was demoted after the race. I'm raising it because I think the treatment isn't consistent with any other race I've seen with a time penalty, and I know if I was losing out on something due to it, I'd be pretty pissed off, especially when so far into something like the Eliminator competition.

I can't think of a single example of a penalty after the flag being applied to points here. Happy to be proved wrong.

   
Chris

Registriert: 04.02.2014
Nationalität: Germany
Beiträge: 686

31.10.2016 00:21:23
 
Thank you frost :p maybe someone has a screenshot of the provisial ranking directly after the flag xD

   
CarlisleFrost

Registriert: 19.03.2009
Nationalität: USA
Beiträge: 132

31.10.2016 00:14:22
 
I can't recall a race where scoring here has taken into account penalties after the race finishes. This one did come particularly soon after the flag, but it was after.

Best example I remember is Silverstone this year.

You gave Rosberg 38 points (9 quali, 24 race, 5 fastest lap). HOWEVER, the official standings in the race had Rosberg 3rd due to a time penalty after the race, which would have driven a score of 37. You went with the pre-penalty standings. You even mentioned that changes after the race don't influence race results on the site.

The right, consistent way to score this one should be Verstappen 31, Vettel 26, Ricciardo 33, then the chassis and engine accordingly.

   
Chris

Registriert: 04.02.2014
Nationalität: Germany
Beiträge: 686

31.10.2016 00:06:28
 
Yes i agree Frost. In qualifying we have the penalty mostly before the competion and they dont count!? This eleminates me
It was a investigation after the race...

   
Maverick

Registriert: 10.01.2004
Nationalität: Austria
Beiträge: 1076

31.10.2016 00:03:18
 
I always have used the first published provisional results. And it is not the first time that there is included a 5 second penality.

   
CarlisleFrost

Registriert: 19.03.2009
Nationalität: USA
Beiträge: 132

30.10.2016 23:54:53
 
Your normal rules was to take positions pre-time penalties. I don't like raising this, as it hurts my points slightly, but in past races, that's the way you've done it. Vettel finished 4th and made the podium due to a penalty applied after the chequered flag.

   
Chris

Registriert: 04.02.2014
Nationalität: Germany
Beiträge: 686

30.10.2016 23:52:13
 
What?? This is killing my last chance in the season. I thought its goallineresult

   
Maverick

Registriert: 10.01.2004
Nationalität: Austria
Beiträge: 1076

30.10.2016 23:49:39
 
No, the scores are correct.

The published provisional results came along with:

3. Sebastian Vettel
4. Daniel Ricciardo
5. Max Verstappen

Vettel was also on the Podium.

I always take the provisional results which are published after the race.

   
  0102



458  
42 Rennen 1  019
3609 (113) Sakhir, Bahrain (18.3.2022-20.3.2022) 344

This website is unofficial and is not associated in any way with the Formula One group of companies.
F1, FORMULA ONE, FORMULA 1, FIA FORMULA ONE WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP, GRAND PRIX and related marks are trade marks of Formula One Licensing B.V.

Copyright © 2003 - 2024 PFRL.net

NORMAL MODE